IAs Indians celebrated independence at midnight, the Director General of the Intelligence Bureau warned that darkness lay ahead. large parts of the country, BN Malik looked vaguely An official report from 1953 saw the disintegration of the police ‘as an effective force’. As a result of poor training and personnel shortages, “the old fear the police used to instill among criminals is largely gone.” “There has been no improvement in the methods of investigation or in the application of science.”
For 70 years – as India battled multiple insurgencies, large-scale communal violence and ethnic conflicts – annual reports by the central government have been cut and pasted same disappointing data on which the famous spymaster based his insights.
Perhaps due to bureaucratic cowardice, or plain-vanilla fatigue, the editorial language has turned blunt. But the reality of Indian Police has still not changed.
Like every year, Budget 2023 is also going to spark a vigorous debate on defense expenditure. The hollowness of the core of India’s internal security – its police force – passes without mention. The constitution gives the responsibility of the police to the state governments. Except for Rs 2,780.88 crore in the budget committed to reimburse the police forces of the states fighting the insurgency, the central government is only responsible for the forces it directly maintains.
To say the story of the Indian police is off-budget but it should be in the middle level. for years, experts have argued A case for reconsideration of Centre-State relations with respect to the police, divided between them by the Constitution. The time is running out for a debate on how the police should be funded and regulated.
Read also: Some hits and misses for India’s agriculture sector in Budget 2023
devil in the details
Even though there is only a small expansion of funding for the police in Budget 2023 – with Rs 1,29,627.52 crore, higher than the revised estimate of Rs 1,20,026.19 for the fiscal year 2021-2022 – there is some welcome evidence that Narendra The Modi government has its priorities right. Forensic Science and Criminology Facilities- Union Home Minister Amit Shah identified correct identification as key for reliable testingReceived a capital allocation of Rs 28.25 crore, which is almost three times more than last year. States will get Rs 700 crore more as against Rs 250 crore.
The cash-strapped Intelligence Bureau, which got just Rs 62.69 crore for capital expenditure in FY 2021-2022 and Rs 65.71 crore in last year’s revised estimates, will have Rs 255.06 crore to spend this fiscal. The National Intelligence Grid, the master database structure that links state and central databases, will also get a sharp increase in funding.
Like much to do with internal security, however, the devil is in the details.
From the latest available data-published last year By Bureau of Police Research and Development (BPRD)—It is clear, the cash-strapped state governments are not able to provide cash for the police. In the year of the deadly 26/11 Mumbai attack, which claimed to have changed the government’s approach towards internal security, states and union territories spent Rs 26,269.09 crore, or 3.88 per cent of their budget, on their police forces. Last year, the proportion increased marginally to 4.13 percent – and the numbers are even more dismal on closer examination.
Lashkar-e-Taiba’s death squads who attacked Mumbai, scholar Paul Staniland recorded, encountered police who were “under-staffed, trained and technologically backward”. that year, the States and Union Territories Rs 413.36 crore was spent on training of police personnel, which is about 1.5 per cent of the Rs 26,269.09 crore police budget; and Officials vow reforms,
In 2022, the money spent by states and union territories on police training was Rs 1,652.88 crore – two-thirds of the Rs 2,480.02 crore budgeted for the purpose and less than one per cent of the expenditure on the armed forces.
The expenditure on police training has actually decreased in the States and Union Territories. There has also been a recurring pattern of state governments and union territories failing to spend the funds budgeted for the police. States and Union Territories spent only Rs 1,53,766.19 crore out of Rs 1,78,338.47 crore allocated in FY 2020-2021 and Rs 1,67,489.15 crore out of Rs 1,94,116.34 crore in FY 2021-2022.
The malaise is endemic. Working in one of the most dangerous environments in India, the Jammu and Kashmir Police spent only Rs 82 crore out of Rs 102.4 crore allocated for training last year. The union territory fared even worse on modernisation, spending just Rs 16.57 crore out of a budget of Rs 150 crore.
Economist even in prosperous Maharashtra Renuka Sane and Neha Sinha Recorded, the budget “barely allocates funds for the operational expenses of running police stations or the cost of maintenance of computer systems, arms and ammunition”. Elsewhere in India, the low budget has forced the police to cut down on essentials such as fuel and ammunition. The lack of police welfare infrastructure has given rise to corruption.
Read also: Budget 2023: An election year bonus for the super-rich. No, the Modi government has not lost it
waving leviathans
The justification for spending decisions isn’t always clear in the numbers. The Delhi Police has been allocated Rs 1,019.92 crore for capital expenditure, almost double that of the Border Security Force, which is set to receive Rs 555.77 crore, and more than five times that of the crucial Indo-Tibetan Border Police. For which Rs 174.61 crore has been allocated. The Special Security Group set up to protect the Prime Minister has received Rs 77 crore for capital expenditure.
The core malaise in the states—spending too much on salaries and not enough on capacity building—affects the central forces as well. The Central Reserve Police Force, the Corps National Police Service, will spend Rs 31,154.09 crore on salaries in this financial year. The force will have only Rs 618.14 crore for capital expenditure.
Faced with cross-border insurgency and violence that threatened to overwhelm the state police, the central government has relied on central forces since the early years after independence. BPRD data shows that there has been a steady increase in the number of central police organizations. From Chhattisgarh to Kashmir, however, central police forces have struggled – local forces have better local knowledge and social legitimacy.
For internal security planners, reducing the number of central police is not an option, as state police forces are already well below strength. The BPRD recorded that state governments and union territories have budgeted to provide 192 police officers for every 100,000 of India’s 1.2 billion population. However, financial constraints mean that there are 150.8 police officers per 100,000 people, well below the UN norm of 250.
The then Home Minister P. Chidambaram raised Alarm On 2010 the number, which was around 160 per 1,00,000, was almost the same as today. Telangana, where Maoist insurgency has erupted repeatedly, should have 218 police per 100,000 residents. The state, says the BPRD, is just 131. Uttar Pradesh should have 185 but pay for 127. Bihar has only 73 per 1,00,000.
The lack of effective police forces has had real consequences for India. Local political actors—from caste elites to outright criminals—have effective power. This has undermined policy formation based on the rule of law. Anemic police forces have often relied on brutality to assert the authority of the state.
For decades, New Delhi has relied on the central police forces—and the military—to address the many crises facing the country. The current model has worked to ensure order, but not law.
Praveen Swamy is ThePrint’s National Security Editor. Thoughts are personal.