Weak arguments: The Hindu editorial on the Trump impeachment and American politics

Former US President Donald Trump has pleaded not guilty to 37 charges related to willful withholding of classified documents from the White House and obstruction of justice in their return. Of these charges, 31 are related to violations of the Espionage Act, some of which can carry a prison sentence of up to 20 years. After appearing in court and entering his plea in Miami, Florida, Mr. Trump was released on bond with the condition that he would not be allowed to discuss the case with a specific list of witnesses . It is the second indictment that has been slapped on the 45th president, following an earlier one related to allegations that he paid secret money to Stormy Daniels, an adult film star, potentially in violation of federal campaign finance laws, a felony. . The latest charges relate to more than 100 classified documents discovered in August at his private residence in Florida, some of which reportedly deal with the defense and weapons capabilities of the US and other countries. According to prosecutors, Mr Trump hoarded and hid the files, and then with the help of an associate, engaged in a conspiracy to obstruct the FBI’s investigation.

Unsurprisingly, both indictments have been used by the Trump campaign to fuel its mobilization efforts, which have included repeated messaging about not only the “witch hunt” but the US president, Democrat Joe Biden and Mr. Including misinformation about Trump’s alleged criminality in the 2016 Democratic primary. rival and former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. It is true that classified documents were also discovered at properties linked to Mr Biden in Delaware, including some dating from his time as senator and vice president, and at the Indiana residence of former Republican Vice President Mike Pence. However, no conclusions have been drawn by the authorities regarding the ongoing investigation into these possible violations. Meanwhile, keeping in mind the 2024 presidential election, every turn of the screw in the Trump cases is being used to rattle the political ecosystem. Voters were already polarized on hot-button issues — from the economy and jobs to reproductive rights and immigration reform. Barring rare exceptions, such as the recent coming together of Republicans and Democrats to raise the national debt ceiling and avoid a spiraling credit rating crisis, bipartisanship has been in scarce supply. The post-COVID economic rebound has been undermined by inflationary fears, and much work remains unfinished to strengthen public health systems. The law will take its course on every investigation into possible wrongdoing by political leaders. Nevertheless, as America enters the deep end of the campaign cycle, it would do well for all parties to shun extremist views and show restraint in focusing on the greater good of all Americans.